Chapter 1

Mastering Vacation Rental Investment: The Go-To Guide

Last updated: May 2025

Have you ever dreamed of owning a place where people from all over the world flock to relax, unwind, and make lasting memories? Vacation rental investments offer a truly special opportunity to combine business with pleasure—literally!

Before you take the plunge into the world of short-term rentals, it’s important to know the ins and outs of what makes this market tick. Get ready to explore the tools, tips, and strategies that will help you turn your property into the ultimate vacation getaway and a valuable income source.

Don’t see the form to download our business plan? Click here.

1. Understanding the vacation rental market

The vacation rental industry has quickly become a major player in the global travel economy.

Unlike traditional hotel accommodations, vacation rentals offer travelers a more personalized and home-like experience. They often include added amenities such as kitchens, private pools, and one-of-a-kind locations.

From city bungalows to beachfront villas, short-term rentals cater to a wide range of preferences and budgets, making them appealing to a wide demographic of travelers. But how can you take advantage of this market?

Pay attention to trends and growth potential

Platforms like Airbnb and Vrbo have revolutionized the way people book accommodations. This change has paved the way for market expansion. Post-pandemic travel recovery has further accelerated growth, with more travelers seeking private and flexible accommodation options.

That being said, travel trends are constantly shifting, so you’ll want to pay attention to anything that might help or hinder your vacation rental. For example, emerging trends such as bleisure travel (combining business and leisure), remote work opportunities, and increased interest in sustainable travel are driving demand for vacation rentals.

Explore popular locations for vacation rentals in the United States

Location plays a critical role in the success of a vacation rental. It directly influences demand and guest satisfaction. Choosing the right location can help attract your ideal target audience and ensure a steady flow of bookings. We’ll explore more of this topic in greater detail later on.

According to AirDNA’s analysis, the following locations are currently among the best places for vacation rental investment in the United States in 2025:

  • Peoria, Illinois
  • Fairbanks, Alaska
  • Akron, Ohio
  • Columbus, Georgia
  • Crescent City, California
  • Shreveport, Louisiana
  • Page, Arizona
  • Rockford, Illinois
  • Dayton, Ohio
  • Frankfort, Kentucky

Consider these key metrics

When evaluating the best locations for Airbnb investments, the following key metrics are important to look into:

  • Occupancy rates: Occupancy rates indicate how frequently a property is booked within a specific timeframe. Higher occupancy rates often correlate with popular destinations and steady demand.
  • Revenue per night (RevPAR): RevPAR measures the average revenue earned per available night. It combines the average daily rate (ADR) with the occupancy rate.
  • Average length of stay: The average length of stay reflects traveler behavior and your turnover costs (like cleanings).

2. Setting investment goals

Before investing in vacation rental property, it’s important to establish clear objectives for your new undertaking. Common goals include:

  • Income generation: How much money does the property need to consistently generate to cover expenses and create a steady cash flow?
  • Long-term appreciation: This focus is on properties that are likely to increase in value over time, aiming for a profitable return upon resale.
  • Blended approach: Some investors combine both strategies. They are looking for properties that offer both reliable rental income and potential appreciation.

Defining your objectives will help shape your investment strategy and determine the type of property and location to target.

Determining your budget and financing options

Understanding your financial limits and funding options is an important step in the investment process. Consider the following factors:

  • Down payment and upfront costs: Calculate how much you can allocate for the down payment, closing costs, and the expenses to prepare the property for rental. How much you put down should be based on your available funds and the type of financing you choose. Generally, investors put down 20-25% of the property’s purchase price.
  • Financing options: Research lending opportunities. These typically include traditional mortgages, vacation home loans, or partnerships with private investors.
  • Operational costs: Account for ongoing expenses such as property maintenance, taxes,insurance, utilities, and property management fees.

Establishing a clear budget and exploring all financing avenues will help you invest wisely and minimize financial strain.

Assessing your risk tolerance

Investing in vacation rentals carries varying levels of risk depending on factors like market conditions, property location, and unexpected expenses. To evaluate your risk tolerance, consider the following:

  • Market volatility: Assess the stability of the rental market in your chosen area. Consider how seasonal fluctuations in demand could impact your income.
  • Vacancy risks: Prepare for periods where the property might not generate income, especially during off seasons.
  • Mitigation strategies: Explore options like reserving cash for emergencies, diversifying your investment portfolio, or purchasing insurance to protect against potential losses.

Understanding your level of comfort with risk will ensure that your investment remains sustainable and aligns with your financial goals.

3. How to choose the right location and property

Choosing the right location for your property is one of the most vital decisions you’ll make as an investor. Begin by identifying areas with high demand for short-term rentals. These typically include places such as:

  • Popular tourist destinations
  • Business hubs
  • Regions with special attractions like national parks, ski resorts, annual events, etc.

You’ll then need to analyze local market trends and occupancy rates to gauge the potential profitability of the area. Additionally, proximity to transportation hubs, such as airports or public transit, can positively affect a property’s desirability.

Be sure to take seasonality into consideration, as demand for short-term rentals can fluctuate throughout the year. For example, properties in beach towns may experience higher occupancy rates during the summer months, whereas ski homes thrive in the winter. Understanding these seasonal patterns will help you plan pricing strategies and set realistic expectations for your occupancy rates.

Finally, pay close attention to home prices in the area. High property costs may impact your return on investment, especially if rental income doesn’t offset expenses like mortgage payments, maintenance costs, and any property management fees. You’ll need to balance affordability with your likely potential revenue.

Consider what types of properties are suitable for vacation rentals in your area

There are various types of properties that can be suitable for short-term rentals, depending on the target market and location. Some common options include:

  • Single-family homes
  • Apartments or condos
  • Shared spaces
    • This could include rooms within a home or shared apartments. This is usually the most budget-friendly option for travelers.

It’s also worth considering more niche properties like cabins, A-frames, geodomes, and treehouses. As travelers continue to value unique experiences, these types of properties can be a worthwhile investment.

Before listing a property for vacation rental, it is important to research the local laws and regulations regarding short-term rentals. Some cities or neighborhoods may have restrictions on certain types of properties, such as only allowing single-family homes to be used for vacation rentals.

Additionally, the size and layout of a property can also play a role in its suitability for vacation rentals. Properties with multiple bedrooms and bathrooms are often more attractive to families or larger groups traveling together. On the other hand, smaller studios or one-bedroom apartments may be more appealing to solo travelers or couples.

Look for features and amenities that attract guests

To stand out in a competitive market, prioritize features and amenities that elevate guest comfort and convenience. This could include:

  • High-speed internet
  • Fully equipped kitchens
  • Outdoor spaces such as patios and barbeque areas
  • Pools
  • Gym access
  • Pet-friendly policies

Understanding the expectations of your target audience, whether they are business travelers or vacationers, will help you tailor the property to meet their specific needs.

Evaluating local regulations and zoning laws

Before making a purchase, it’s necessary to understand the local regulations and zoning laws governing short-term rentals. Some areas may have strict rules, such as limits on rental periods, licensing requirements, or bans on specific types of properties.

Researching these regulations in advance will help you avoid costly legal issues or restrictions that could impact your investment’s profitability. Consulting with a local real estate expert or attorney can provide valuable insights and ensure you remain compliant with all laws.

4. Calculating costs and ROI

When investing in a short-term rental property, it’s essential to consider all upfront costs to understand the true initial investment. The purchase price of the property is the most significant expense. However, additional costs like the ones below can add up quickly:

  • Closing fees
  • Inspections fees
  • Taxes
  • Furnishings
  • Appliances
  • Decor

For example, high-quality furnishings can attract more guests and justify higher nightly rates, but they also increase your initial outlay. Additionally, you may need to invest in renovations or upgrades to make the property more appealing to renters.

Recurring expenses

Owning a short-term rental involves ongoing costs that are critical to account for in your budget.

Maintenance and repair costs, both routine and unexpected, are inevitable and ensure the property remains in excellent condition for guests. Utilities such as electricity, water, internet, and cable are necessary to keep the property functional and comfortable.

Property management fees should also be factored in if you plan to hire a service to handle guest bookings, cleaning, and overall upkeep. Other recurring expenses may include:

How to project rental income and calculate ROI and cap rate

Understanding potential rental income is a key step in evaluating the profitability of your short-term rental. Research comparable properties in your area to estimate average nightly rates and occupancy rates. Be realistic in your projections, factoring in seasonal fluctuations and local demand.

Once you have a clear idea of your income, subtract all your recurring expenses to determine your net cash flow. Calculating the return on investment (ROI) involves dividing your annual profit by your initial investment, then multiplying by 100 to express it as a percentage. A strong ROI indicates that your property is performing well financially and meeting your investment goals. Follow the formula below to easily calculate your ROI:

ROI = (Net Annual Rental Income / Total Investment) × 100%

Another important metric to consider when evaluating real estate investments is the capitalization rate, or cap rate. The cap rate is used to determine the potential return on a property by comparing its net operating income (NOI) to its purchase price or current market value. It is calculated using the following formula:

Cap Rate = (Net Operating Income / Property Value) × 100%

A higher cap rate often signals a higher return, but it can also involve higher risk. Cap rates are particularly useful when comparing multiple properties or assessing the profitability of an investment relative to its market value.

Pay attention to your municipality’s specific short-term rental guidelines. These typically include:

  • Zoning restrictions
  • Permit requirements
  • Limits on the number of rental days allowed per year
  • Specific vacation rental insurance coverage

Additionally, earning an income from a vacation rental property comes with tax responsibilities. Rental income is generally taxable and must be reported on your tax return. However, property owners may be eligible for valuable deductions, such as expenses for:

  • Maintenance
  • Mortgage interest
  • Property taxes
  • Utilities

Do your best to maintain detailed financial records and consult with a tax professional to ensure compliance and maximize deductions while adhering to IRS regulations.

6. Tips for long-term success

Running a short-term rental is a business and, like any other business, requires continuous effort and attention to ensure long-term success. Here are some tips for maintaining a successful short-term rental:

  • Regularly assess your pricing.
  • Stay up-to-date with local regulations.
  • Pay attention to industry trends.
  • Build strong relationships with guests.
  • Keep track of expenses and income for tax purposes.
  • Regularly review guest feedback and address any concerns.
  • Continuously look for ways to stand out from the competition.

What to take away from vacation rental investments

Investing in vacation rentals can be a rewarding endeavor if approached with the right strategies and mindset. By staying informed, maintaining excellent standards, and fostering positive guest experiences, you can maximize your success and ensure your property remains a sought-after destination. With careful planning and consistent effort, vacation rental investments can yield both financial rewards and personal fulfillment.

And, of course, if you need help managing your new vacation rental investment, Lodgify is here for you. Start a free 7-day trial to see firsthand how Lodgify can help you build a direct booking website, sync your listings across all your booking platforms, and automate your business.

Don’t see the form to download our business plan? Click here.